“ We got a Magherita & half cheese and pepperoni for my kids. I thought it was pretty good. Thing that was weird about this place is that there's like 3 different names for it...one on the side of the wall...one on this website and another at the door...so we were a little confused about if it was the same place. ”

“ Manhattan Bros is the kind of place that might go unnoticed, but once you discover it, you realize it offers some of the best pizzas in all of Tampa. This cozy establishment is run by its owners, which is evident in the quality and care put into each pizza. The wood-fired pizzas at Manhattan Bros have an incredible flavor, with a perfectly crispy crust and fresh ingredients that make every bite delightful. Plus, the prices are very reasonable, making it an excellent choice for both a casual dinner and takeout. It's our favorite place to order pizzas, and we're always satisfied with the quality and service. If you're looking for a pizzeria that combines authentic taste and great value, Manhattan Bros is definitely the best option in Tampa. ”

“ This is your typical two-table paper plate pizza shop with a bathroom behind the kitchen that I've eaten in 500+ times before all over America. The location is a basic slice shop in a little strip center. The pizza man was friendlier than most, courteous, and made some really excellent food. They lose a star for not having ice and offering the flimsy white plasticware (the kind with the fork tines that snap under the slightest pressure) but otherwise it was all on point and top end (5-star for Tampa Pizza) I'm not saying this is John's of Bleeker or Joe's in the Village, or Sally's aPizza of New Haven but it is really tasty for Tampa. We had an order of 6 garlic knots and an 18" pie half pepperoni and half mushroom. The knots were garlicky-buttery-goodness with just the right level of fluff. The pizza had good toppings, good sauce, and nice crispy-chewy (but not dry) crust. It was worth whatever they charge (I wasn't thinking about the price, frankly). We will be back. ”

“ Brother, for $ 6.99 you get two slices and a drink. Not the best NYC style in the world, but it beats Sbarro and I'm betting a fresh pie would hit hard. We had window slices, so not knock just not the best they put out. ”

“ Being from the north east, we know NYC pizza real well! My son recommended this new pizza shop, and since Manhattans in the name will give it a shot. My husband and I walked in 3 o'clock on a Saturday afternoon we ordered three slices some garlic knots, and we were not disappointed at all. The pizza was thin, crusted super hot Largest pizza slices I've seen since Greenwich Village. We finished all three slices and one of the knots and then realized as we're looking through the menu that we need to take an eggplant Parmesan hero home. Well we walked out to the car looked at each other and said better eat half that Parmesan hero now don't want it to get cold , it was full of eggplant split open browned under the broiler, eggplants, peeled, sliced, thin. easy to eat. Bread was great. Small shop several tables inside you can eat with friends and family. The owner was very accommodating and friendly. Get the menu. Take it home. Use the coupons go here as often as possible. ”

“ Best pizza I've had so far in Tampa. Great friendly service, in a cozy feeling place. 100% going again pizza was so good. ”

“ This is probably one of the best pizza places I've experienced in Tampa. Great NY style crust, good sauce, and quality ingredients. Their florentine pie is also one of my favorites. We order from here about once a week and are never disappointed in the quality, and it always arrives hot and with friendly service. ”

“ Very plain, simple interior with a few TVs mounted, probably more for staff than customers. Upon entering, waited about 5 minutes before being acknowledged as another customers lunch was being prepared. Ordered the special, 2 slices and a drink, this includes two slices of cheese pizza and a soft drink or water. The slices were huge! And cheesy and oh so greasy. Manhattan Pizza is a great name because it definitely gives you that greasy, cheesy pizza you'd get in NYC. Be sure to grab lots of napkins! ”

“ Favorite new pizza place in Tampa! Found it through Yelp's "hot and new restaurant" search and we continue to come back frequently. The pizza is exceptional - thin, crispy, fresh and has amazing flavors. The wings, salads, and chicken fingers are also great. The family style service is incredible. The owner and head chef are genuine and go out of their way to make it a great experience each time, always remember us, and thank us for returning. They go above and beyond each time, the last time offering our daughter pizza dough to play with and make her own pizza. Exceptional pizza and customer service! ”

“ Delicious pizza, it was exactly what I needed. I'm from the northeast and we are serious about our pizza. Cute little family owned spot! ”